JK Rowling and Philip Pullman have changed the answer to that question. Do we expect the new dispensation will allow them to escape their categories as well?
But some of us here at Shmoop are both girls and want to go on treasure hunts, so we still love this book. Robert Louis Stevenson gives us a main character with whom his desired audience of ordinary boys can identify: Sure Jim Hawkins is a little more imaginative and adventurous than many, but he is still average enough to be relatable.
Jim is the only child of English innkeepers in an unspecified decade of the 18th century.
Still, we like to imagine that, if we found a treasure map and fell in with a bunch of pirates, we would muddle through OK like Jim does. Part of what makes him so likable is that he comes out OK without there being anything special about him. We can totally see why, because it involves a boy going on an adventure.
He has to make some kind of personal transition over the course of fighting pirates and finding treasure, right? You can change and still remain a kid — otherwise, childhood would be completely boring and static.
And how applicable is fighting pirates to his everyday life back in England? He has not moved on or gained closure or however you might put it — the island is still a place of fear that haunts his dreams.
So it seems problematic to say that Jim began the book as a boy and has now become a man. That said, this is a book about a teenager taking initiative and saving a bunch of adults from pirates, which is a pretty mature thing to do.
Jim as Narrator So Jim is our trusty narrator well, except in the three chapters that get taken over by Doctor Livesey. This shows us a couple of things: Second, Jim is more than just our main character.
Robert Louis Stevenson is using a pretty common storytelling strategy for the 19th century.
But Jim gives us a bit of a twist. When David Copperfield, say, analyzes his own past life, he discusses the lessons and emotional consequences of what happened to him. He keeps his emotional commentary to a minimum.
Take, for example, when Jim writes: Sometimes the isle was thick with savages, with whom we fought; sometimes full of dangerous animals that hunted us; but in all my fancies nothing occurred to me so strange and tragic as our actual adventures.
But nothing that Past Jim pictured in his mind was as weird and terrible as what actually happened. But these feelings seem to tell us less about Jim than about the plot of the story and how much fun is in store if we keep reading.Keywords: Stevenson, Treasure Island, moral ambiguity, dual nature Introduction Robert L.
Stevenson () was born and educated in Edinburgh. Throughout his whole life, Stevenson suffered from serious tuberculosis, and of that disease he died.
As is well known, Stevenson’s life spanned a very tumultuous period of the British Empire. Treasure Island is not a book with a message; instead, it is an adventure tale, pure and (except for the character of its great antagonist, John Silver) simple.
Yet like some other adventure tales, Stevenson's classic novel has as its central theme one of the oldest and most universal stories. Robert Louis Stevenson's Treasure Island is a coming-of-age story and quest narrative about a young English boy, Jim, who joins other buccaneers in island of buried treasure, when he finds a treasure map in the chest of an old sailor named Billy Bones.
Keywords: Stevenson, Treasure Island, moral ambiguity, dual nature Introduction Robert L. Stevenson () was born and educated in Edinburgh.
Throughout his whole life, Stevenson suffered from serious tuberculosis, and of that disease he died. As is well known, Stevenson’s life spanned a very tumultuous period of the British Empire.
The following entry presents criticism of Stevenson's novel Treasure Island. For a discussion of Stevenson's novel Strange Case of Dr.
Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (), see. See also Markheim Criticism. Treasure Island: the Journey of Jim Hawkins Essay. Coming to Terms With Evil in Treasure Island Robert Louis Stevenson's novel, Treasure Island, is a fast-paced adventure tale about a boy developing into an adult and coming to terms with the presence of evil in the world.
More about Treasure Island: the Journey of Jim .